DIY marketplaces build your sales but complicate product returns

Blog

DIY marketplaces build your sales—but complicate product returns

Third-party marketplaces are the largest and fastest-growing retail channel globally, expected to account for nearly two-thirds of all online sales by 2027. Third-party marketplaces are an easy way for sellers to grow their SKU depth, attract new shoppers and boost site traffic, all without the capital outlays associated with owned inventory. It’s easy to see how the expanded third-party product offerings of B&Q, Home Depot, Lowes and other do-it-yourself (DIY) retail giants create a win-win for both buyers and sellers.

Shoppers can browse today’s third-party DIY marketplaces, with their hundreds of thousands of SKUs, from the comfort of their home and enjoy one-stop shopping. By purchasing products from an established DIY retailer who now functions as a third-party marketplace, consumers can combine the lowest online price, the exact product they’re seeking, and the brand strength and logistics capabilities of a retail powerhouse.

DIY retailers who embrace the marketplace model can sell more, hold less, gain strategic insights and build relationships. The proven benefits include:  

  • Unlimited aisle expansion. Retailers can add products without the burden of inventory ownership, warehousing and fulfillment overhead. 
  • Search-powered sales growth. Marketplace participants capture high-intent traffic from long-tail product searches that would otherwise go elsewhere. 
  • Brand halo effect. DIY sellers can grow revenues by offering new brands and niche solutions under the trusted umbrella of their retail name and infrastructure. 
  • Cost efficiency. Marketplaces enable DIY retailers to offload labor, logistics and customer service for non-core SKUs to third-party sellers. 
  • Behavioral insights at scale. Shopper data captured from third-party traffic and purchases drive segmentation, personalized offers and future assortment optimization.

 

While third-party marketplaces represent an enormous opportunity for DIY retailers, they do have one significant drawback. As product returns volumes skyrocket—accounting for $890 billion in merchandise in 2024—the addition of a third-party seller can add exponentially to the complexity of product returns. 
 

Stop struggling with DIY returns

Discover how an AI-powered supply chain can revolutionize your process, making it more efficient, resilient, and profitable.

DIY returns challenges are only amplified by marketplaces

DIY returns are notoriously operationally expensive. Why? They often consist of bulky and oversized goods that exceed small-parcel norms. Hazardous or regulated items, including paint, power tools and chemicals. Kits and bundled items with non-uniform repackaging rules. They have low refurbishment viability due to wear, installation or damage risk. Two-man handling or scheduled pickup are required for certain categories.

Now layer in a third-party marketplace and the complexity multiplies, including:

  • Disjointed seller policies, with no uniformity in timelines, channels or resolutions
  • Fragmented reverse logistics, where returns may need to go to the seller, not you
  • Blurry shopper expectations because consumers bought “from you” and expect you to resolve the issue
  • Store associates who are in the dark, forced to turn away marketplace returns they can’t process
  • Hidden costs associated with sorting, restocking and disposing of unrecognized SKUs erode margins
  • Reputational risks because consumers blame your brand, not the seller, for a failed returns experience

 

Even if your organization is a leader and innovator that’s already invested in digitized processes, clear rules and policies, early visibility of returned products, and other best practices, you may still face challenges in running a third-party marketplace. How well do your own internal policies and processes mesh with dozens or hundreds of third-party sellers—who each have their own standards and practices?  

Inconsistency leaves consumers confused—and, when they can’t easily find an answer, they’ll likely default to your brand. Imagine the all-around frustration when a consumer shows up in-store with a large, unwieldy product—and your employees have to turn them away.

The twisting, inconsistent and poorly defined path returns take through a third-party marketplace often represents a losing proposition for DIY retailers. Consumer satisfaction is not in your control, so shopper loyalty and your brand reputation might be damaged. Reverse logistics drives up costs quickly, especially when large products and third parties are involved—erasing the benefits of making a sale in the first place. From a sustainability standpoint, third-party product returns are less likely to make it back into sellable inventory quickly, and more likely to end up in a landfill.

Take complete control as you take back products

How can DIY retailers capture the advantages of participating in a third-party marketplace, while minimizing the negative impacts of returns? It’s simple. They must achieve the same level of visibility and control over every product return, regardless of where it originates. They need to establish consistent returns practices, policies, timelines and consumer experiences across every channel and every product, including third-party offerings. Instead of differentiating returns by channel, the answer is creating a universal returns gateway for all products, across all channels.

That’s a challenging proposition. But Blue Yonder’s industry-leading returns management capabilities make it much easier.

Blue Yonder helps DIY retailers create an online returns portal where every buyer can initiate a product return, regardless of where the product sale originated. Detailed insights are created during this initiation process: Where did the sale originate? Who is the seller? What is the product’s condition? Where is the consumer located? At what location, and through what channel, is the product most likely to be resold?

Because this is a complex set of questions, artificial intelligence (AI) is applied to determine how to quickly and cost-effectively get each returned item back into sellable inventory, whether in your warehouse or a third-party warehouse. Then Blue Yonder AI optimizes the journey, step by step.

DIY marketplace consumers might receive a digital QR code to launch the process. They might drop the product off at a carrier, return it to store or drop it off in an in-store kiosk. Whatever the optimal route determined by Blue Yonder—and guided by your rules governing third-party marketplace sales—the consumer receives an intuitive map showing where to drop off the product. And just like that, the return is on its way.

Blue Yonder gives you complete control over DIY marketplace returns. Don’t want to touch third-party products? You’ll never have to. Send consumers to a carrier or a drop box that’s managed by your seller. Want to drive shoppers into your store, where they might make an additional purchase? Send them to your local customer service counter or an in-store kiosk.

From the shopper’s perspective, the returns experience remains the same, whether they’ve purchased your product directly from you or a third-party seller. You remain in control of the shopper relationship and can protect your brand image.

Intelligently and automatically identifying the origin of every return, and mapping the right path, also makes a huge impact on your speed and cost outcomes. By having Blue Yonder AI flag third-party products and send returns directly to the right vendor, you’ll eliminate the need for your employees to manually sort third-party returns from your own inventory. With early visibility of the return, its timing and the product’s condition, both you and your third-party sellers can get the right resources in place to get sellable merchandise back into inventory, fast.

Master your marketplace returns

Protect your brand and boost your bottom line with our 6 expert steps. 

 

Master the returns path of every product, in every channel

The problem of product returns is growing, and it’s only getting more complicated with the rise of new channels like third-party marketplaces. But don’t overlook the significant revenue opportunity promised by these newer channels.

Blue Yonder can help you maximize your results from a third-party marketplace, while also optimizing the journey of inevitable product returns. It’s all about applying AI and decision science, maximizing speed, and integrating returns into your end-to-end supply chain—even for products that originate outside that supply chain.

Want to learn more? Watch our new video on Blue Yonder’s returns management solutions, or reach out to us to talk about your own specific marketplace returns challenges. We’re here to help!